Posted by: CJ | December 23, 2009

Other Absurd Beliefs

In addition to my most absurd belief, I have a host of other beliefs that might be characterized as absurd.

  1. Nature vs. Nurture. I come down pretty hard on the side of nurture. As far as I can tell from research summaries I’ve read, not to mention my own experience, nature mostly matters when all other things are approximately equal. Most importantly, that includes the prevailing culture, education level, and resources of someone’s family/guardians. But I think the culture, education level, and resources of someone’s family are stronger predictors of performance than anything genetic. Not to mention there don’t seem to be mechanisms for how exactly the genetics affects things, only fancy statistical tests. This makes me suspicious.
  2. Value of Education? Even though I consider Robin Hanson, at Overcoming Bias, and many economists, more than a little crazy and taken with their theories, I think they have a bit of a point about modern university education. A common argument for the value of higher education is that even if the students don’t use skills they were taught in college, they do use critical thinking abilities they learned. I like this idea, and hope it is true. However, it’s very untestable. An alternative idea, pushed by economists, is essentially that higher education is used as a signaling device to advertise you have a particular middle-class culture, work ethic, desire for wealth, and basic level of skills. In other words, it’s just a sorting device for employers to use, and it’s left up in the air whether  what you were taught matters at all. That alternative argument is also hard to test, but it appeals to my cynical side a great deal.
  3. Much Academic Research is Overvalued. I have a belief, somewhat patently absurd, that most academic research is of very little value. While many people might feel comfortable saying that about philosophy, humanities, or social science research, I’m anomalous in extending it to physical and biological science fields as well. It’s true that we’re making all sorts of new discoveries and publishing all sorts of new findings, but it’s unclear what difference academic research is making, despite the onward march of new products and technologies. This isn’t a belief I can defend in any way, and it’s easy to knock down in many specific circumstances. But I often feel it’s true nonetheless.
Advertisements

Responses

  1. […] I’m also more sensitive to it because they touch on my most absurd belief and one of my lesser (deeply held) absurd beliefs. Because, you know, I think it’s important to point out I thought the world was doomed before […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: